Home
About
Archives
Articles


This page is an archive from the previous version of The Row Boat, which is why it doesn't look and work the same as the current version. However, these archives are fully functional and integrated with the new system.



Why does this site permit advertising?
Click here to discuss.



Creative Commons License

Powered by Little Logger





The Row Boat

"Had we but world enough, and time..." *






Quantifying Hope

2/18/2007 10:23:42

Things appear to be terrible! The U.S. government, already knee deep in (at least) two failing foreign wars, is trying to throw a third one at Iran, most likely the most disastrous of them all. Meanwhile, evidence is gathering that the activities of human beings (especially in this country) are causing conditions that will make this planet less and less habitable. We have talked about these things quite a bit already. As people, too, "there is only so much that we can do." But so much badness still needs to be overcome. Even so, one cannot know the full effects of one's action and presence until Eternity and Omniscience. To lose hope, however, is the first error, and the worst. Hope, like love, never fails because it is its own success.

I once heard (from Chris Marker's film "Sans Soleil") that there was a time in Japanese history when the nobles were kept almost prisoner by the emperor at court to ensure that he would keep his grip on the realm, like Louis XIV at Versailles. One of the things they did to pass the time was to make lists of everything imaginable, and they turned it into such an art form that it finally molded the imagination of the whole culture.

So maybe it would help us, even as we struggle, and while struggling we wait, to make clear what can be hoped for.

First, there are a few things we can give up on:
that people will do what we want them to do
that God will do what we want him to do
the things that seem most important will always be so

The list of what absolutely cannot be given up on is much, much more expansive:
unexpected things (some of them good) will happen
God's work will be accomplished
both activity and presence have inevitable effect
more injustice in the world is possible
less injustice in the world is possible
suffering is possible
joy is possible
people do not live by bread alone
the future hasn't happened yet

If you have any suggestions for a list like this, I am eager to know them. Please help! I know there is so much more but my mind is feeling slow for some reason.




re:Quantifying Hope - 2/18/2007 18:16:44
Posted by jake

I very much like the sentence:
"Hope, like love, never fails because it is its own success."

After reading it again, I now am confused about the worth of success. also the worth of attempting to hope and failing.

Also, if you are still looking for things not to be given up, I might include something about agency; that each of us, no matter how powerful or impotent we may feel, still have some choice and control over our lives and our world.

Best.




re:Quantifying Hope - 2/19/2007 07:48:12
Posted by Barbara Kay Croissant

Things We Cannot Give Up On:

1) Everything in this world shall pass.
2) Truth, the Absolute encompass the world we see and are beyond the world we see.
3) There is purpose in suffering.
4) Peace is always within and is eternal.
5) Peace is attainable by human effort and by turning within.




re:Quantifying Hope - 2/20/2007 09:36:27
Posted by nathan

Thank you for these ideas! Keep them coming. Actually, in the first incarnation of this site, before it was called the Row Boat, there was a running "list of absolute certainties." I thought that was a fun idea, to see what people of all sorts on the internet could actually agree on as absolutely certain (if anything).

Currently on my own I am trying to compile a list of Known Heresies. Let me know if you have any ideas for that one.

Seeing hope as its own end comes to me through Kierkegaard's Works of Love, which demonstrated to me that faith, hope, and love are not means but ends. Of course Paul's letters say this, but it was Kierkegaard (and the experience of trying it out in life) that helped me to understand it.





Printer-friendly version


Name:

Email:

Subject:

Type in your comments below. Visit the styleguide for a list of suggested HTML tags.

Prove you are not a machine!
Please enter the 4-digit year that this post was originally submitted, which is given at the top of this page directly under the title and next to the date (e.g. 2005 in 9/18/2005 44:33:22)

Creative Commons License
The Row Boat basks under a liberating Creative Commons license